The Other Birthday
Critic:
Jason Knight
|
Posted on:
Nov 27, 2024
Directed by:
Gabriel Brown
Written by:
Giulia Vascotto
Starring:
Sarah Seymour, Joseph Hammal
Megan (Seymour) and Tom (Hammal) are a young couple and live in a nice house, with their dog, Boots. However, things are not well as the two of them do not talk to each other. Megan appears to be sad, quiet and distant, while Tom is attempting to keep the spirits high by playing with Boots and being sociable. Eventually, a birthday party for Boots at their home organised by Tom will upset Megan and make her confront her issues.
The script and the acting add significant qualities. With a story that takes place in a household where happiness and sadness coexist, this short's well-crafted screenplay manages to be uplifting and melancholic simultaneously. The film's dramatic atmosphere is supported by Lucy Green's music that includes wonderful piano melodies and the song Bittersweet View by Eli Hartley and Rebecca Romeo Pitone was a great choice to end the film with. Speaking of the ending, big commendations go to the animation during the closing credits.
There is a moment later on in the film (which we won’t spoil) which could have been enhanced with more context for the viewer but this may be down to personal taste. The narrative succeeds very effectively in establishing the pain caused by the couple's loss, however, it would have probably been even more dramatic if the viewer had further context behind this.The reason for Megan's reserved and sad state is not revealed until the end, making it a mystery why she seems so unhappy and the revelation is quite emotional.
The strong performances (assisted by strong direction from Gabriel Brown) by Seymour and Hammal are vital factors in creating a dramatic atmosphere. Megan is struggling to come to terms with her emotional pain and appears to be unable to embrace any sort of happiness, which is wonderfully portrayed by Seymour. On the other hand, Hammal’s performance as Tom is cheerful and acknowledges the fact that life must go on. Together, the performers capably depict the couple’s differing attitudes on dealing with a devastating tragedy and supporting the main conflict in the story.
The themes the film raises include the aftermath of loss and grief, the pain it causes and (on a positive note) about the significance of support and not ignoring the good parts of life, even when things are bad because pleasant experiences can help make things better. And of course, the joy that pets bring is also acknowledged.
This is a poignant and heart-warming story that contains valuable lessons about life. It indicates that tragedies can heavily affect people and that people should not forget about the happiness that can be found in those around them.