Guacamole Yesterdays
Critic:
Joe Thomas-Fox
|
Posted on:
Nov 20, 2026

Directed by:
Jordan Noel
Written by:
Hudson Phillips
Starring:
Sophie Edwards, Randy Havens, Adentipo Thomas
“I'd love for audiences to walk away questioning whether our lives are defined by our past circumstances and trauma or whether we have the power to take the reins and redefine our own stories,” is what screenwriter and producer Hudson Phillips said about the low-budget, independent sci-fi romantic dramedy Guacamole Yesterdays. After a devastating separation, cartoonist Ames, played by Sophie Edwards, begins therapy with a specialist, played by Adetinpo Thomas, who employs an experimental technology that enables Ames to relive and reshape the memories of her relationship with her husband, Franklin, played by Randy Havens. As Ames revisits moments from their first date to their final goodbye, the boundaries between memory and reality start to dissolve.
This is a perfectly well-done, if somewhat unremarkable, story about the nature of human memories and the trauma of heartbreak. What’s needed at the centre of any romantic story is a strong and believable couple, and that is something that Guacamole Yesterdays gets right. Sophie Edwards and Randy Havens both give competent performances, and thankfully they do have solid chemistry. Their characters are genuinely well-written – they have actual personalities and feel three-dimensional, with their individual traits resulting in believable interactions and conflict. This is a film that has drawn plenty of comparisons to Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, and the sci-fi element at the centre of the story allows it to look at its themes and ideas in a way that isn’t completely generic.
Despite these solid elements, as well as the fact that the film as a whole does a perfectly solid job of exploring its themes and getting its key messages across, I can't honestly say I was invested in this the whole way through. The directing isn’t particularly memorable, and I felt that the script and dialogue could have been more consistently sharp. The film is certainly not free of emotional impact, but there was too little about this that stood out for it to be an experience that deeply moved me or stuck with me. The film consistently changes aspect ratios, and while the intentions and reasons behind this choice are clear, it just doesn’t add much to the experience as a whole. The musical score is limited, but when it does happen, it’s generic and forgettable. There are stretches of this film that are just less engaging than others. It’s possible that it could have benefitted from a slightly shorter runtime, although spending less time with these characters does come with the risk of the impact of the story’s conclusion being softened.
Although Guacamole Yesterdays may not be as memorable or consistently strong as it could have been, it's a decently effective exploration of heartbreak, memories and the importance of facing trauma, led by a solid and believable central couple. It’s also able to have sci-fi elements at the core of its story without doing anything overly ambitious that could result in the film being hurt by its limited budget, and that’s something that’s particularly inspiring.
.png)



